Ceramic vs carbon vs dyed tint
Dyed, carbon and ceramic are three ways of making window film. Dyed film is the cheapest and mostly gives privacy. Carbon film holds its color and blocks more heat than dyed. Ceramic film blocks the most heat at any shade and costs the most. New Shade Tint installs dyed film (XPEL PRIME CS) and two ceramic films (PRIME XR and XR PLUS), and does not sell a carbon film.
All three kinds of film can be bought in the same shades, so two cars can look identical from the curb and feel very different inside at 4 PM in August. What changes is the stuff inside the film that deals with the sun.
Side by side
This table compares the categories. Exact numbers depend on the brand and the product line, so the only figures given are for the films New Shade installs.
| Dyed | Carbon | Ceramic | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it works | Dye in the film absorbs light | Carbon particles in the film | Nano-ceramic particles tuned to block infrared |
| Heat rejection | Lowest | Middle | Highest |
| Privacy and glare | The same at the same shade. Both follow how dark the film is. | ||
| Color over time | Cheap dyed film can fade or turn purple. Color-stable dyed film is made to resist that. | Holds its color | Holds its color |
| Phone, GPS, toll tag | No interference | No interference | No interference |
| Price | Lowest | Middle | Highest |
| At New Shade | XPEL PRIME CS, up to 35% IR | Not sold | PRIME XR, up to 85% IR PRIME XR PLUS, up to 96% IR |
IR figures are XPEL's published "up to" ratings. All three PRIME films block 99% of UV.
Dyed film
Dyed film is the original window tint. A layer of dye darkens the glass, cuts glare and hides what is in the back seat. It does little about infrared, which is the part of sunlight a driver feels as heat on an arm.
Its reputation comes from bargain film. The purple, bubbled back windows on older cars are dyed film whose dye broke down. Better dyed films are built to keep their color, and XPEL PRIME CS is one of those: the CS stands for color stable. It is the entry film at New Shade and it has the same lifetime warranty as the ceramics.
Pick it when the goal is the look and the privacy, or when the budget is fixed.
Carbon film
Carbon film swaps the dye for carbon particles. Carbon does not fade the way dye can, and it blocks more heat than a dyed film does. It has no metal in it, so it leaves phone and GPS signals alone. Many shops sell it as the middle option.
New Shade does not carry one. The XPEL PRIME line the shop uses goes from a color-stable dyed film straight to ceramic. A customer who walked in wanting carbon is choosing between two things: PRIME CS if the draw was the lower price, or PRIME XR if the draw was heat rejection.
Ceramic film
Ceramic film carries particles small enough to be invisible that are chosen for one job, blocking infrared. That is why a ceramic film can be light and still keep a cabin cooler than a dark dyed film. XPEL rates PRIME XR at up to 85% infrared rejection. PRIME XR PLUS is a multi-layer ceramic and is rated up to 96%.
The drawback is price. Ceramic costs more because the material does. At New Shade, sides and back start at $199 in PRIME CS and $299 in PRIME XR. The cost guide lays out the rest.
What a customer gets for the money, in one customer's words: "Alex is the best at what he does. My windows are perfect. Do to the ceramic tint I now run my A/C blower speed on 2 on 100+ degree days."
Josh Taylor, Google review
What about metallic film?
There is a fourth type that comes up in older comparisons. Metallized film uses a thin metal layer to reflect heat. It works, but metal can get in the way of phone, GPS and radio signals, and Texas caps how reflective the front windows can be at 25%. New Shade does not install it. None of the XPEL PRIME films contain metal.
Is ceramic worth it?
It depends on what the tint is for.
If the car lives outside, has a dark interior, or carries kids in the back through a Texas summer, ceramic is the film that fixes the problem the owner is trying to fix. PRIME XR is the one most New Shade customers pick. PRIME XR PLUS is for the people who want the most heat stopped, which matters on black interiors and long commutes.
If the car is garaged, leased for two more years, or the owner just wants it to look finished, PRIME CS is a fair choice and there is no reason to be talked out of it. Alex will say which one he would put on the vehicle. Customer A Young wrote that Alex "helped me understand the pros and cons of the different options available for my vehicle."
One mistake to avoid is buying darkness to get coolness. Going from 35% to 5% in a dyed film changes privacy a lot and heat much less, and 5% is not legal on the front doors in Texas anyway. See tint percentages and the Texas tint law guide.
Where to go from here
The ceramic window tint page has more on XR and XR PLUS. The automotive tint page shows all three films with prices and walks through the install. A full windshield is done in ceramic only.
